Why Did My Car Insurance Go Up?

Written by |

Have you gotten hit with a big premium hike on your auto insurance — even though you haven’t had any accidents or tickets? It’s happened to plenty of people. We’ve got an answer to the question: “Why did my car insurance go up?”

6 Factors That Can Secretly Drive Your Car Insurance Up

If you get notice of a premium increase from your insurer, it may seem like your insurance is going up for no reason. But that’s usually not the case, according to money expert Clark Howard.

“First off, the number of accidents is going up because of distracted driving. And, second, with so much technology being built into cars, the cost of repairs has skyrocketed. So, you have a lot of vehicles that would once get fixed being declared a total loss by insurance companies and they have to pay for that.”

But there are other reasons.

Table of Contents

  1. Credit Score Changes
  2. Change of Address
  3. Roadside Assistance
  4. Relationship Status Change
  5. Not-at-Fault Accidents
  6. Mileage Change

1. Credit Score Changes

Have you recently missed a payment, charged up a lot of your available credit or opened new store credit cards? Each of these things will temporarily lower your credit score.

But if you think insurance should be a merit system based on how many claims you’ve made, rather than your financial state of being, you’re not alone.

“The whole credit score thing in insurance drives me to distraction,” Clark Howard says. “If you’re paying more than you think you should be based on your driving record, this could be the reason why.”

2. Change of Address

A 2015 study from the Consumer Federation of America (CFA) found that many auto insurers set rates not based on customers’ driving records but rather their street addresses.

Progressive and Farmers were both singled out as two insurers who do this the most.

Of course, this factor can work to your benefit, too. For example, our team member Sally and her husband moved a while back but forgot to update their address with their auto insurer. When their auto insurance premium increased, they were looking for ways to lower the bill.

It turns out the solution was as simple as informing their auto insurer of their new address!

“By updating the address with our auto insurance, our bill decreased by $10 every month ($129.30 to $119.64),” she says. “So the recent increase was offset by our new location savings.”


3. Roadside Assistance

Clark has talked before about the danger of using roadside assistance or free towing from your insurance company.

Some auto insurers treat your use of roadside assistance as an at-fault claim and forward the information for inclusion on what’s known as your C.L.U.E. report. If you have too many claims on your C.L.U.E. report, it will make you “radioactive” to other insurers. That effectively locks you in with your current insurer because it limits your ability to shop with competitors.

“That ‘free tow’ could be the most expensive tow you ever have,” Clark says.

The solution here is to skip the roadside assistance from your insurance company and get it from a third party such as AAA. It won’t report your use of roadside assistance to any centralized insurance industry database.

4. Relationship Status Change

So what’s the connection between relationship status and what you pay for car insurance? Let’s just say that “It’s complicated,” to borrow a phrase from Facebook.

Married couples statistically file fewer claims than drivers who are single, divorced or widowed. That’s why when a single person gets married, they’ll typically save $96 annually on policy premiums, according to The Zebra’s State of Auto Insurance report.

Unfortunately, the reverse can be true, too. If you get divorced or become widowed, there’s a chance you may be charged more for your policy because of the unfortunate change to your relationship status.

However, we should note that some states ban the use of marital status in setting insurance rates.

5. Not-at-Fault Accidents

It’s unfortunate but true: If you’re involved in any way in a not-at-fault accident, some insurance companies will jack up your rates.

One member of Team Clark found that his auto insurance rates spiked by 15% when a neighbor who parked next to him banged up his car while leaving a parking space. Our team member was not at fault and wasn’t even present when the damage happened! Yet his premium went up anyway.

A study from the Consumer Federation of America quantified which insurers are most likely to penalize not-at-fault drivers. Progressive was the single worst offender, followed by GEICO, Farmers and Allstate.


6. Mileage Change

The final factor that could potentially drive up your car insurance is a change to your commuting pattern.

An increase in annual miles driven from 5,000 to 20,000 translated to a 9% average rate increase, according to a InsuranceQuotes.com study.

However, we should note this factor will impact only people who are either regularly self-reporting mileage to their insurer or using a telematics device for pay-as-you-drive insurance.

Final Thoughts

As you can see, there are a number of possible answers to the question of “Why did my car insurance go up?” It may seem like it happens for no reason, but that’s usually not the case.

In addition, there are also larger industry trends at play driving up your rates periodically.

“Insurance companies are always doing this back-and-forth between fighting for market share and increasing profits,” Clark says. “When they’re fighting for market share, they keep premiums low. But when they feel like they have enough market share, they need to make a profit. So they have to raise premiums. It’s a never-ending cycle.”

Of course, nobody wants to be stuck paying an unnecessarily high premium. If that’s where you find yourself, you need to re-shop your auto insurance. Also, it is important to know how much car insurance you need.

And, you’ll want to see our list of the best and worst auto insurance companies.

But here’s one caveat when you’re shopping around: Don’t be lured in by an unusually cheap premium. That often means one of two things: You’re either getting lesser coverage or you’re getting it from a company that doesn’t have a good reputation.

“Sometimes you’re better off paying a little more to be with a quality insurer who will be there when the chips are down,” Clark says.

Welcome bonuses can be a great way to boost the value of a credit card. Best Credit Card Sign-up Bonuses for 2023 - Team Clark spent hours reviewing the market for credit card sign-up bonuses and evaluated them according to the guidelines for usage set by money expert Clark Howard. Clark believes credit cards with exorbitant annual fees are a bad idea for most…
Team Clark's cell phone expert ranks the best cell phone plans and deals. Best Cell Phone Plans in 2024: The Cheapest Plan for Every Need - Team Clark ranks the best cell phone plans and deals! See our favorites for unlimited data, families and cheap plans starting at $10/month.