Should I Buy a Used Car, New Car or Lease Right Now?

|
Advertisement

The vehicle market continues to be a wild one: Prices are sky-high and in some cases, used cars cost even more than new ones. So what about leasing instead?

That’s the question a listener of money expert Clark Howard‘s podcast asked recently.

Should I Lease a Vehicle Right Now?

Because of the inflated prices of both new and used vehicles currently, you may be thinking of leasing a vehicle and then perhaps purchasing it after the lease is up.

Clark says it’s OK to consider leasing a car right now but told the listener, “It seems like you’re creating unnecessary complications in your life, because leasing costs are going to be inflated just like purchase costs.”

Should I Buy a New or Used Vehicle Right Now?

For years, Clark has recommended buying used vehicles that are around three years old so you don’t have to eat the initial depreciation. But because of the current market, Clark has advice that is a departure from what he has said previously:

“Right now, it makes sense to buy new instead of used with how ridiculously inflated used vehicle prices are,” Clark says.

“I can’t think of another time in my career … that buying new has potentially been — particularly for long ownership-cycle owners — has been typically a better decision right now, in the second half of ’21 and now in ’22, than buying a one- or two-year-old used car,” he says.

How Do New and Used Car Prices Compare?

As an example, prices for a 2022 Honda Accord on Edmunds.com range from $26,000 to $38,000 depending on deluxe features. I found a brand-new LX model for $27,135.

2022 Honda Accord LX for sale on Edmunds.com
Screenshot Via Edmunds.com

I found prices on CarMax.com for used Honda Accords, LX model year 2020, that range from around $26,000 to nearly $37,000.

Used Honda Accords for sale at CarMax.com
Screenshot via CarMax.com

How To Shop for a New Car Right Now

Work Out the Financing

Don’t waste your time thinking about buying vehicles you can’t afford. The crucial first step is to get pre-qualified for a car loan through a credit union or online bank.

Once you get the financing worked out, you can shop with confidence because you know how much car you can buy.

Advertisement

Do Your Research

You don’t have to visit car lots physically anymore, although you can if you want to.

The top car-buying websites make it easy by showing their inventory online. Once you’ve chosen some candidates, schedule your test drive to see if you like the car.

Be Flexible

Bear in mind that you may have to make some concessions on the make and model. If you really want a leather interior, you may be able to save some money – and time – by opting for a car with a cloth interior (which should be a little cheaper).

Also, instead of other deluxe features, you may increase your chances of getting the make and model you want by settling for a vehicle with fewer bells and whistles.

Read more on how to buy a new car.

Final Thoughts

Clark says even if you consider leasing a vehicle, you’ll pay more for it because of the car industry’s high prices right now. And while he usually prefers that you buy a used vehicle, the fact that some new cars are currently cheaper than their older models makes it OK to opt for new vehicles in this market.

“Right now, one-year-old vehicles are usually selling for more than what people pay for them new,” he says. “That’s freaky weird. And that’s why if you can wait for a new one to come in — which is why people are paying more for used ones because you can get it that day versus waiting for a new one that you order — it’s really better to buy brand new rather than one-year-old.”

More Car Resources From Clark.com:

Advertisement
Welcome bonuses can be a great way to boost the value of a credit card. Best Credit Card Welcome Bonuses for 2022 - If you're in the market for a new credit card in 2022, you may be hoping to cash in on the hundreds of dollars in sign-up bonuses offered to new customers. Welcome bonuses and offers are a marketing tool that…
The best cell phone plans include Tello, Mint Mobile, Visible, T-Mobile, Consumer Cellular and more Best Cell Phone Plans in 2022: Deals for Every Budget - Team Clark ranks the best cell phone plans and deals! See our favorites for unlimited data, families and cheap plans starting at $10/month.